Film is a great way to bring esoteric ideas to a greater audience. So I had high hopes for Margin Call, a movie that is meant to portray dramatically the actions of the financial emperors who cut the world economy off at the knees.
It could have worked. Look at the cast. Kevin Spacey, Stanley Tucci, Jeremy Irons. What a crew. And the bad guy from Heroes and Paul Bettany to boot. Talk about power brokers. It
could have worked. Cast, plot, setting, timing – amidst a popular revolution that is finally emerging to combat the unassailable forces the movie seeks to demonize. There’s just one thing.
It’s boring.
They kill it with unnecessary melodrama and overcomplicate it by layering on vague allusions to how “big” this terrible, unnamed thing is that is going on.
It honestly popped into my head a couple of times that the movie might be a very clever backhanded compliment crafted by Karl Rove republicans. An attempt to swiftboat the popular movement spearheaded by the Occupy Wall Street protests. (I don’t honestly think that)
I kept thinking of what I’d tell people if they asked me what it was about: “Well, it’s full of drama, people saying things, and acting!”.
No shortage of acting in Margin Call. Heaps of it. Layers of it. Meandering roads of it, steaming piles of it.
But sometimes it works! Some scenes really are intense. Some scenes are poignant. Some scenes play perfectly and are great achievements. But some are just downright silly.
Maybe I’m being a little too harsh. I suppose the movie could still help strengthen the movement. It could at least make some people curious about the fraud, the outright criminal activity that lead to millions of people losing their ability to provide for themselves and their families. Criminal activity for which the perpetrators were handsomely rewarded with bailouts by the US government.
(aside – I do think that the bailouts of the banks were necessary and helped keep this country and the greater world from the depravity of a full depression)
While it’s possible that Margin Call may help to bring the perpetrators of the financial crisis into the public spotlight, it does nothing to help Americans understand the nature of the crisis, the political and legal legerdemain* that lead to it.
And in that, I feel like Margin Call does the public, and the movement, a disservice. If a movie comes along now, that really does all that, does help bring understanding of the steps that lead to the Great Recession, the public’s response may well be: “Eh. I already saw a movie about the crisis. I guess it was okay, but I don’t need to see another one”.
I still love Stanley Tucci and Jeremy Irons though. And this guy Paul Bettany is cool.
No wait, I got it – nothing is fucked here! They could still come out with a roman-a-clef epic about the forces that lead to the great depression. Yeah, that could work. It could be a movie in which the resolution is the crafting of the Glass Steagall act
*(forgive me)